Skip to content
Independent · No gambling offered · 18+SearchSavedAdvertise
Sunday, 15 November 2026Vol. I · No. 42
Updated 18+Play responsibly
Markets
FLUT81.13▼ 1.02%DKNG18.89▼ 1.20%MGM33.49▲ 0.75%LVS40.39▲ 2.70%WYNN85.06▲ 2.46%CZR29.33▲ 0.17%PENN17.50▼ 0.17%CHDN99.72▲ 0.10%LNW120.37▼ 1.53%RSI11.86▲ 0.51%EVO871.00▲ 0.62%BETS96.80▲ 0.47%ENT4.75▼ 0.04%GXY33.42▼ 3.07%SCL10.67▼ 3.26%ALL66.34▲ 2.03%
Regulation

Federal judge rejects Novig's claim its sports contracts are swaps

A New York federal judge has refused to treat Novig's sports contracts as protected financial swaps, leaving the state free to pursue enforcement against the prediction market operator.

a judge's gavel on a wooden desk
Photo: Patrick Feller from Humble, Texas, USA (CC BY 2.0) via Openverse

A federal judge in New York has refused to let Novig, a prediction market operator, treat its sports contracts as financial swaps outside state gambling law. In a 35-page opinion issued on Tuesday, US District Judge Colleen McMahon denied Novig's request for a preliminary injunction against New York Attorney General Letitia James and the state's gaming regulators, according to Casino.org.

The case turns on which federal rules apply. Novig argued that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), the federal law governing derivatives trading, prevents New York from enforcing its sports betting laws against the company. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regulates that law, and in June it designated Novig a contract market. Novig said its contracts were swaps governed solely by the CFTC, and therefore beyond the reach of state gambling regulators.

Novig's exchange looked a lot like a sportsbook

Novig runs an exchange where customers trade against each other on sports outcomes, rather than betting against a traditional sportsbook. McMahon accepted that sporting outcomes count as “events or contingencies” under the CEA. She ruled, however, that they lacked the inherent financial or commercial consequences needed to make a contract a swap.

She pointed to the product itself. Novig’s point spreads, player props and parlays, which combine several selections into one bet, were indistinguishable from bets offered by FanDuel and BetMGM. One four-game NFL parlay offered a payout larger than 111 times the amount wagered. The judge also noted that Novig had held a Colorado sports betting licence before giving it up to move to its federally regulated exchange model.

Novig's sports event contracts are sports bettingJudge Colleen McMahon, US District Judge, in her opinion

The CFTC's position draws the judge's sharpest words

McMahon reserved her harshest language for the CFTC, which has been trying to draw a line between financially traded sports contracts and traditional sportsbook bets. She found the agency's recent stances contradictory and wondered whether it had tried to influence the ongoing litigation.

She went further on one order. According to the ruling, a CFTC order that prevented a rival platform from shutting down while New York filed legal action “smacks of a collusive effort” to create a conflict under federal law. She also argued that even if Novig's contracts were swaps, federal law would not automatically displace New York's long-standing authority over gambling.

A New York licence or an exit from the state

The ruling clears the way for the state to take enforcement action. If that happens, Novig would have to secure a New York gambling licence or cease operations in New York. The decision does not, however, compel Novig to shut down, and the case itself is not over.

The judge described the ruling as preliminary, not a final word on the lawsuit. It adds to an increasingly disparate set of court rulings across the United States on whether sports prediction markets fall under federal or state authority. For now, operators and states are left without a single answer, and readers wanting a wider view of recent decisions can follow our tracker of the biggest gambling regulatory moves since early October.

Frequently asked questions

What did the New York judge decide about Novig's sports contracts?

Judge Colleen McMahon ruled that Novig's sports contracts are essentially sports bets rather than financial swaps protected by federal law. She denied Novig's request for a preliminary injunction against New York Attorney General Letitia James and the state's gaming regulators.

What is a swap, and why does the classification matter for prediction markets?

A swap is a financial derivative contract regulated under the federal Commodity Exchange Act by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Novig argued its sports contracts were swaps, which would place them outside New York's gambling laws, but the judge found they lacked the financial or commercial consequences needed to qualify.

Does the ruling force Novig to stop operating in New York?

The ruling does not compel Novig to shut down. It does leave New York free to take enforcement action, which would require Novig to secure a New York gambling licence or cease operations in the state.

Why did Novig give up its Colorado sports betting licence?

Novig held a Colorado sports betting licence before giving it up and moving to its federally regulated exchange model. Judge McMahon cited this history in her opinion when assessing whether the company's products were in substance sports betting.

What is a parlay bet?

A parlay is a single bet that combines several selections, with all of them needing to win for the bet to pay out. Judge McMahon noted that Novig's parlays were indistinguishable from those offered by FanDuel and BetMGM, including one four-game NFL parlay with a payout larger than 111 times the stake.

What role did the CFTC play in the Novig case?

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission designated Novig a contract market in June, which Novig used to argue its contracts were swaps governed solely by federal law. Judge McMahon criticised the agency's recent positions as contradictory and questioned whether it had tried to influence the litigation.

Is this ruling the final decision on the Novig lawsuit?

No. The ruling is preliminary, and the judge described it as the latest addition to a patchwork of court rulings across the United States. The wider question of whether sports prediction markets fall under federal or state authority remains unresolved.

This report is based on Casino.org News, checked and rewritten by the Casino Courant desk. Spotted an error? Tell us.

More on United States, Prediction markets

Casino Courant is independent and does not offer gambling. We do not take payment for editorial coverage. 18+. Gamble responsibly.