Federal judge rejects CFTC bid to halt New York action against Kalshi
A federal judge has declined to stop New York from pursuing enforcement against Kalshi, leaving the dispute to play out in state court.

A federal judge has refused a request from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to block New York from pursuing enforcement action against Kalshi, the prediction market operator. According to Gambling Insider, the court declined the agency's emergency bid, so the dispute now moves forward in the state system rather than being paused by a federal order.
The CFTC is the federal regulator for US derivatives markets, and its oversight covers the event contracts offered by exchanges such as Kalshi. The emergency bid was an application for a temporary restraining order, a short-term court order that pauses a dispute while a judge considers the wider case. The judge did not grant that order, which means New York's action can continue.
Why the federal regulator went to court
The CFTC's position in disputes of this kind has been that event contracts traded on a federally registered exchange fall under federal commodities law. On that view, individual states do not have the same power to restrict them that they have over casino games or sports betting. The agency has therefore sought federal court orders to stop state authorities from acting against such contracts.
New York and other states have taken the opposite view. Their argument, in general terms, is that contracts tied to sporting results or other outcomes can amount to gambling under state law, and that state gaming authorities are entitled to act against unlicensed offerings within their borders. The report used for this article does not set out the specific claims in New York's enforcement action, so the precise scope of the state's case is not yet clear.
For readers, the distinction is more than technical. Whether a contract counts as a financial product or a gambling product determines which regulator has authority, which consumer protections apply and whether a state can require a licence.
What the Monday state court hearing could decide
The ruling clears the way for a state court hearing on Monday. A hearing at state level means a state judge will consider the state's case against Kalshi and the company's response to it, rather than a federal judge weighing the CFTC's request for a pause. The report does not say what outcome either side is seeking at that hearing.
If New York obtains restrictions, the practical effect could be on whether Kalshi can keep offering certain contracts to customers in the state. That outcome is not known, and no ruling on the merits has been reported. Any decision by the state court could also be appealed.
Federal and state authority over prediction markets is still contested
Prediction markets have drawn attention from several states, and regulators have disputed whether these contracts should be treated as gambling. A federal court's view on whether the CFTC can block state action would be closely studied by other states and by operators that rely on the same federal framework.
For the gambling industry, the case is a reminder that legal risk now sits between two layers of government. Operators that offer event contracts face the prospect of conflicting orders from different authorities, and the outcome of the New York proceedings could shape how quickly those disputes are resolved.
Readers who want the wider picture can follow our roundup of the most important gambling regulatory moves, which places court rulings and state actions in one list.
This article is based on a summary of the Gambling Insider report, and the full judgment and court filings were not reviewed. The reasoning of the judge and the scope of New York's enforcement action should be checked against court records and fuller reporting as they become available.
Frequently asked questions
What did the federal judge decide in the CFTC case against New York?
A federal judge declined to grant the Commodity Futures Trading Commission an emergency temporary restraining order that would have blocked New York from pursuing enforcement action against Kalshi. The refusal means New York's action can continue, and a state court hearing is scheduled for Monday.
What is a temporary restraining order?
A temporary restraining order is a short-term court order that pauses an action while a judge considers the wider case. Such orders are usually sought on an emergency basis, when one side argues that waiting for a full hearing could cause harm. In this case the CFTC asked for one against New York, and the judge refused.
What is the CFTC?
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is the US federal regulator responsible for derivatives markets. Its oversight covers the event contracts offered by exchanges such as Kalshi. In this dispute the agency is arguing that federal rules should limit what individual states can do.
Why is New York pursuing enforcement action against Kalshi?
The report used for this article does not set out the full claims in New York's enforcement action against Kalshi. New York and other states have argued that certain event contracts can amount to gambling under state law. The specific basis of the New York case is not detailed in the source.
When is the state court hearing in the Kalshi case?
A state court hearing in New York's action against Kalshi is scheduled for Monday, according to the Gambling Insider report. The federal judge's refusal cleared the way for that hearing to go ahead. The report does not give the exact date or the name of the court.
What are prediction markets?
Prediction markets are platforms where people trade contracts whose value depends on the outcome of future events. Kalshi is one operator offering such contracts in the US. Whether these contracts are financial products or gambling is the central question in disputes with state regulators.
Could the Kalshi ruling affect other states?
Other states may watch the New York proceedings closely, because the question of federal versus state authority applies beyond one state. A federal court's view on the CFTC's power to block state action could influence similar disputes elsewhere. The outcome in New York is not yet known.
This report is based on Gambling Insider, checked and rewritten by the Casino Courant desk. Spotted an error? Tell us.
More on Prediction markets
Casino Courant is independent and does not offer gambling. We do not take payment for editorial coverage. 18+. Gamble responsibly.


